Saturday, February 23, 2008

Grab a chair for a long review of Saturday's college basketball action

I’m not going to waste much on an intro here because it’s a long post about today’s games with NCAA tournament implications on and off the bubble. What a Saturday though!

VCU 57 – Akron 52

Going into today neither of these teams likely were going to have a shot at a bid but VCU was more likely than Akron. This game keeps VCU alive as they could have a chance if they make a run in the CAA tournament and everything else falls just right around them. It seems likely that VCU should try to take the automatic bid anyway.

Connecticut 65 – Villanova 67

Villanova has tossed themselves right back on the bubble and if they can win their next game, at home against Marquette, they’ll likely be sitting on the right side of the bubble. It was just a huge win for Villanova. Connecticut’s hopes for a Big East title took a beating today but they’re not dead yet because the rest of their conference schedule is pretty easy.

Cincinnati 53 – Georgetown 73

Cincinnati has actually played pretty well in conference play so I’m actually impressed with the ease of this victory.

Maryland 63 – Miami 78

Miami is now on a huge four game winning streak and they’re in pretty good position to get a bid. Maryland has now lost two in a row and their next two games are @Wake Forest and Clemson. If they drop them both they could be done. This was one of the bigger bubble games of the day.

New Mexico 72 – Utah 69

New Mexico now has a manageable RPI and their next two games are at home against BYU and UNLV. If they can hold serve at home they’d likely be in pretty good position to grab a bid. Keep an eye on the Lobos. This was a huge win for them today. Utah isn’t great this year but winning on in Salt Lake City still is not easy.

Rutgers 48 – Marquette 78

Any other result would be stunning.

Iowa 52 – Michigan State 66

Hey, this is nearly twice as many points as Michigan State scored in Iowa City! The game was never close as Michigan State jumped out to a huge 20-1 early lead.

Arkansas 58 – Kentucky 63

With every win it’s getting harder to ignore Kentucky and their RPI is slowly going from horrendous to embarrassing to horrible to now where it’s merely really bad. I don’t think Kentucky will have much to worry about if they can hold serve at home and win at South Carolina; their RPI will take some big leaps if they can beat Mississippi and Florida at home. They’re looking at possibly 18-11 going into the SEC tournament and that would put them in good shape. Billy Gillespie has put together an incredible mid-season turnaround thanks to being in a pretty bad conference. Arkansas would have been in terrific shape with a win today and even with the loss they’re OK but they may need to win 3 of 4 to end the year and I’m not sure they’re capable of it.

Georgia Tech 84 – Virginia Tech 92

Virginia Tech is still clearly on the wrong side of the bubble. However, they are 7-6 in the ACC and they have two more home games before a season finale at Clemson. If they can hold serve at home and pull off the upset at Clemson it’d be real hard to keep them out. The Hokies are alive.

Creighton 65 – Oral Roberts 64

Oral Roberts was probably dead already but Booker Woodfox’s three was a final dagger into their at large hopes. I still expect Oral Roberts to get in and I would not be surprised if a lot more of the country knows about Robert Jarvis in a month.

Oklahoma 45 – Texas 62

Oklahoma is now only .500 in conference. They should be able to win at least 3 of their final 4 and that should be enough but the Sooners have to be considered on the bubble right now. Texas has got to be one of the more underrated teams in the country, particularly by me. I’m starting to come around but this team is almost never one you hear about as a possible national title contender and you rarely even hear about them as a potential one seed. At this point it would be an upset for them not to be a one seed.

Oregon 65 – UCLA 75

Oregon’s at large hopes would have been so much stronger with a win at Pauley. OK, that’s really obvious, but instead as it stands there’s a good chance they’ll need to win their final three games to even be in the picture. That’s possible but there hasn’t been a lot in Oregon’s play this year to suggest it’s likely.

Georgia 74 – Vanderbilt 86

I would have been surprised by anything but this. Vanderbilt has a huge chance for a statement win at home Tuesday against the Vols.

St. John’s 56 – Duke 86

This is not interesting.

Nebraska 65 – Texas A&M 59

With this loss I’m officially guessing that Texas A&M is a favorite to win this season’s NIT. With a 6-6 conference record, a poor RPI, and a finishing schedule of Texas Tech, @Oklahoma, @Baylor, and Kansas, I don’t see them taking even two of these games. Obviously this means the opportunity is still there for the Aggies to cement their bid with some huge wins but I don’t see a lot of evidence to suggest that will happen. They’ve lost their last two home games to Oklahoma State and Nebraska!

Mississippi State 61 – South Carolina 56

This was a huge overtime win for Mississippi State. They’ll probably be in good shape if they just take their two home games (Auburn and LSU) but if they can add a win at Vanderbilt or Florida to that mix they’ll be in easily. This is still a bubble team but they’re probably on the right side of the bubble right now. They should join Kentucky in the “I’m really thankful that the SEC is bad” club.

Kansas 60 – Oklahoma State 61

What? What happened? Oklahoma State? Really? This might have blown Kansas’s chance at a one seed. That’s probably a bit too strong, but they probably need to win the rest of their games until Selection Sunday.

UNLV 73 – Wyoming 65

UNLV avoided a bad loss and now have 3 of their last 4 at home. That one road game at New Mexico will be huge.

Drake 71 – Butler 64

This might have been the most enjoyable game I’ve watched all year. Butler is still solid and I don’t think anyone will want to play them in March but Drake is clearly in that category as well (unless the mind-numbingly dumb Hubert Davis gets his way and Drake fails to even make it in). That alley-oop to Leonard Houston was one of the prettier plays I’ve seen this year. Josh Young was obviously fantastic but I loved the play of Drake’s Adam Emmenecker (despite a boatload of turnovers) and Butler’s Matt Howard. Hopefully Drake begins getting the credit they deserve.

By the way, any Butler fans that might be reading would be well advised to stop whining about every call. Whining about obvious calls makes you seem less credible when you whine about the genuinely poor calls. Over the course of the game there were several questionable calls in Drake’s favor but Butler also had a 4-5 possession stretch with a questionable call/no-call on each possession that all went Butler’s way. The whining and throwing things on the floor took a little away from an otherwise outstanding game that Drake clearly deserved to win. (That’s right Butler fans; get over yourselves. Just enjoy the great team that you get to root for.)

Arizona State 77 – Washington 63

My goodness that was a massive win for Arizona State. Now they return home for two against UCLA and USC. Taking one would be awfully big as they are still suffering from horrible computer numbers. The Sun Devils are squarely on the bubble now but things should get clarified some in their final four regular season games considering the competition they will face.

Mississippi 49 – LSU 69

Remember when Mississippi was 15-1 and their lone loss was by two at Tennessee? I remember watching that Mississippi-Tennessee game and deciding there that the Rebels were for real; they were battling in Knoxville. Geez, since then they are 3-7 and one of those wins was against the powerhouse Presbyterian (only by 11, by the way). This was a real beatdown. You would be kind to include Mississippi in bubble talk at this point.

Providence 53 – West Virginia 80

West Virginia couldn’t afford to lose this game and they really didn’t come close. Providence is not this bad so I’m moderately impressed by the ease of this victory.

Rice 62 – Houston 71

Houston must have slept-walked through this game because Rice is horrible. Still they avoided the horrible loss and they’re still alive.

Indiana 85 – Northwestern 82

Man, for Indiana to only win by 3 I would have guessed they would have had to be distracted and play as though there was something else on their minds. Otherwise I don’t understand this game being this close.

Kansas State 92 – Baylor 86

So, it turns out that Michael Beasley is good at basketball but this was a tough loss for Kansas State. If the season ended now they’d be in great shape but the problem is the season does not end now and now they get Texas and a trip to Lawrence. I wouldn’t say they need to win one of those but it would be awfully nice. Baylor absolutely needed this win. They are once again in OK shape especially considering none of their final 4 games are unwinnable.

Oregon State 53 – USC 81

This is apparently a huge win for USC because the Beavers are pretty positive that they’re no where near as bad their record and they want to fight.

LA Monroe 75 – Western Kentucky 86

Calling Western Kentucky on the bubble is likely generous but I’ll keep an eye on them until they lose again.

UAB 73 – SMU 59

UAB is alive but they still might need a big win to put on their resume. If they can win their next four then their season finale at Mempis will be huge.

Tennessee 66 – Memphis 62

This really was a fantastic game and I would not be disappointed if I get to see it again. I’m still stunned, however, at how bad Memphis is at shooting free throws. I know it’s nothing new but they are really, really bad at free throws. I might go out on a little limb and say that if these teams were to meet again Tennessee would win a bit easier, maybe by double digits. That first half shooting performance by Memphis was impressive and I think more impressive than is normal. Even then they did not have a big lead. I should add that this game probably did convince me that I’ve been underrating Derrick Rose. I had not been sold him much before but he really is solid. I’m still not completely convinced he’s one of the nation’s top 5 freshmen, however.

Arizona 65 – Washington State 55

It’s hard to describe how huge this was for Arizona. Watching the second half of this game, Arizona definitely looks like an NCAA tournament team and a pretty good one at that. Then again, they have lost a ton of games (granted, against a ridiculous schedule). I refuse to say Arizona is in the tournament yet because their schedule to finish up is not easy but this game might be the difference between probably in and probably out. I’m going to go ahead and say it now and that is I don’t see much from Washington State this year. We’ll see how they finish out this year but I could see them drawing a seed where they’ll get a losable first round game and if I had to bet on whether they would or would not make the second weekend, right now I don’t see them making it.

BYU 65 – San Diego State 69

San Diego State is not bad so this wasn’t a horrible loss for BYU and they can survive it and still get an at large bid. However, their lead in the Mountain West is now much more tenuous and they need to travel to New Mexico Tuesday in a gigantic game. I think they can survive one loss on this two game road trip but I’d be less confident with dropping both games.

Kent State 65 – St. Mary’s 57

Kent State looked really comfortable early but then the Gael defense really took over for a good stretch of time. That really was a fantastic performance by Al Fisher, particularly that reverse lay-in with a little under a minute to play. This really might have been a must win for the Golden Flashes, and what a gutty performance they put together. Kent State’s chances at an large bid went from unlikely to there’s a pretty good shot. St. Mary’s should still be OK for an at large bid but their San Diego rematch on Monday just got a lot more important.

Friday, February 22, 2008

Three Posts In One Day!!! A Friday Recap and Criticizing ESPN

Q: Do I really like this Davidson team?

A: Yes.

In the first half as soon as Stephen Curry decided to stop turning the ball over every time he touched the ball they pulled away. And don’t be fooled into thinking this is a bad Winthrop team. Sure, it isn’t as good as it’s been in previous years (like last year) but this is still a team that has been able to beat decent teams including Georgia Tech, Akron, Old Dominion, and Miami.

Curry gets a lot of press for how good he is, and rightfully so. Actually tonight Curry was a liability and it would have been uglier than 60-47 had he hit a normal percentage of his shots. But this entire team is so smart and they were able to get that first half lead with him on the bench a lot of the time due to foul trouble. (By the way, if that first half is any indication perhaps Jason Richards should stop that whole passing thing and shoot more.) They run their offense and get great shots (and it helps the rest of the team when a defense has to be terrified of Curry all the time even when he misses everything like tonight). I’m not sold on the post play and they could run into trouble against big athletic teams but guarding them is a chore. Their defense also didn’t appear too shabby, but part of that is I don’t think Winthrop is a great offensive team. I wouldn’t want to see this Davidson team anywhere near me in March.

Because this was the only meaningful game today I want to comment on a couple of questions on Dana O’Neil’s chat on ESPN today.

Will (Potomac Falls, VA): Dana, I was wondering who you think will win this weekend, Tennessee or Memphis and why? Thanks.

Dana O'Neil: (2:04 PM ET ) Will: I was already to go with Tennessee with the upset but I think the worst thing that happened to the Vols was that UAB game. No way Memphis doesn't have its eyes wide open for this one and at home, that's tough. So I'm going with Memphis in a great, close game.

OK, so what you’re saying is that Memphis would not “have is eyes wide open” if they didn’t almost lose at UAB? The Memphis players are incapable of getting up for a game against the #2 team in the country without it being preceded a couple games ago by an almost-loss? That’s what you’re saying? OK, awesome. I think everyone knows most of Memphis’s players are dumb but I didn’t realize they were that dumb. Thanks Dana O’Neil!

Robbie (Huntsville, Al): Hello Dana. What will Kentucky have to do to get to the big dance? Thanks!

Dana O'Neil: (2:22 PM ET ) Robbie: Win the SEC Tourney and get an automatic bid.

First of all, I do not like these kinds of questions. It assumes that the outcomes for one team occur in a vacuum; you can have no idea what they need to do unless you know what everyone else has done. Despite this, Kentucky clearly does not need to win the SEC Tourney. They currently sit at 8-3 in the SEC and finish up with Arkansas, Mississippi, @Tennessee, @South Carolina, and Florida. Although early in the year they were losing to anyone and everyone at home, in conference play they are undefeated. It is not farfetched to claim they could win their three home games. Then that leaves away games at Tennessee and at South Carolina. Even if they just take the South Carolina game and lose at Tennessee they’d sit at 12-4 in the SEC and 18-11 overall. Considering this very possible scenario I imagine they would only need to not take a bad loss in the SEC tournament to be a strong candidate for an at large bid.

Brian (Manorville, NY): Do you think that Kansas could defeat strong teams like Memphis, Tennessee, and UNC in the tournament?

Dana O'Neil
: (2:35 PM ET ) Brian: I do. Kansas plays great defense and is so deep.

So this is the brilliant analysis we get from ESPN. Stop the presses everyone! Kansas can beat good teams! In fairness to O’Neil perhaps her flaw isn’t so much as an analyst as much as she just picks horrible questions to answer.

It's Your Lucky Day; Back-to-Back Posts!!

So, after giving you a look at the Week's BlogPoll I wanted to give you all today's view of the bubble.

Fridays are often pretty slow in college basketball with really only Davidson-Winthrop of interest today. Winthrop is not as good as they have been the last couple of years but they should still present a nice test for Davidson (and it’s really a game Davidson needs to win if they want to stay in that at-large discussion even if I’d be really surprised if they need it).

So, with tonight’s action being slow I decided this would be a perfect night to take another peek at what the tournament field may look like as of today. As before, first I picked out the conferences that I only project as getting one bid.

  1. America East
  2. Atlantic Sun
  3. Big Sky
  4. Big South
  5. Big West
  6. Colonial
  7. Horizon
  8. Ivy
  9. MAAC
  10. Mid-American
  11. Mid-Eastern
  12. Missouri Valley
  13. Northeast
  14. Ohio Valley
  15. Patriot
  16. Southern
  17. Southland
  18. Southwestern Athletic
  19. Summit
  20. Sunbelt
  21. Western Athletic

I should mention that obviously not all of these conferences were created equal. In these conferences Butler (Horizon) and Drake (Missouri Valley) are getting bids regardless. In addition it is worth keeping an eye on VCU (Colonial), Kent State (Mid-American), Davidson (Southern), Oral Roberts (Summit), and South Alabama and Western Kentucky (Sun Belt). Of these teams I think realistically only Kent State, Davidson, and South Alabama have a shot at an at large bid. Kent State will probably need a Bracket Buster win at St. Mary’s for a fantastic non-conference road win. Davidson will need to win out probably to the conference title game if they want an at large bid, and South Alabama stayed alive with their fantastic win at Western Kentucky last night. VCU, Oral Roberts, and Western Kentucky likely have too much to overcome.

Next I looked at the teams that are locks for bids.

  1. Duke
  2. North Carolina
  3. Xavier
  4. Georgetown
  5. Louisville
  6. Connecticut
  7. Notre Dame
  8. Marquette
  9. Wisconsin
  10. Purdue
  11. Indiana
  12. Michigan State
  13. Texas
  14. Kansas
  15. Memphis
  16. UCLA
  17. Stanford
  18. Washington State
  19. Tennessee
  20. Vanderbilt

There are a couple of teams noticeably absent from this list. The big three are Clemson, Pittsburgh, and Kansas State. All three teams are likely safe but there was just enough there that made me cautious. Clemson doesn’t need much else but I still don’t have a ton of confidence in their ability to avoid messing up. That’s likely influenced by last year. Pitt returns home to face Louisville and Cincinnati now before going to Syracuse and West Virginia. Really he only game there I expect them to win is Cincinnati but Cincinnati has already beaten them once this year. Still, is 0-4 out of the question there? I wouldn’t expect it but it’s possible. After that they get a relative freebee against DePaul. I also think Kansas State is in good shape but they did just lose at Nebraska and their next three games are @Baylor, Texas, and @Kansas. The thing is they could lose all three of those and still have a shot at a bid but if I were a Wildcat fan I wouldn’t want to test it. I still easily put all three of these teams in but I wasn’t confident enough to call them locks. Anyway, let’s add them now.

  1. Clemson
  2. Pittsburgh
  3. Kansas State

That left 21 bids. After doing this I had problems looking at the rest of my field so I started eliminating bubble teams. My method of eliminating teams was basically I decided to cut them off if I thought their inclusion would make me physically ill (or at least more physically ill than my wife’s flu has made me already). I cut out the following teams (many of which are on the bubble of even being on the bubble): Virginia Tech, North Carolina State, Villanova, UAB, New Mexico, Oregon, Arizona State, California, Mississippi, and Kentucky. The two here that I maybe cut prematurely were Oregon and Arizona State but Oregon is currently not a tournament team and Arizona State is probably not a tournament team now and I don’t think they will be after they finish off their difficult schedule. This left me with the following as a final group of teams that were available for those leftover bids.

  1. Maryland
  2. Miami
  3. Wake Forest
  4. Massachusetts
  5. St. Joseph’s
  6. Rhode Island
  7. Dayton
  8. West Virginia
  9. Syracuse
  10. Ohio State
  11. Oklahoma
  12. Texas A&M
  13. Baylor
  14. Houston
  15. Brigham Young
  16. UNLV
  17. USC
  18. Arizona
  19. Mississippi State
  20. Arkansas
  21. Florida
  22. St.Mary’s
  23. Gonzaga

That left only 23 teams for 21 bids! This is the weakest bubble I can remember. I decided that my weakest two teams in that group were Dayton and Baylor but I can listen to other suggestions.

So, the purpose of this was not so much to rank the bubble teams yet as much to figure out where the bubble is. Perhaps come the end of the weekend I’ll feel like I have enough data to actually do some ranking of these teams but I feel like it’s still too big of a group and it’s still too fluid.

Week 15 BlogPoll

I really should try to do this earlier because this BlogPoll is from results through Monday night. Anyway, first here is the Bizarro Joe Lunardi entry.

  1. Memphis
  2. Duke
  3. North Carolina
  4. Tennessee
  5. Kansas
  6. Texas
  7. Xavier
  8. UCLA
  9. Connecticut
  10. Stanford
  11. Louisville
  12. Butler
  13. Kansas State
  14. Purdue
  15. St. Mary’s
  16. Notre Dame
  17. Georgetown
  18. Wisconsin
  19. Vanderbilt
  20. Washington State
  21. Drake
  22. Indiana
  23. Michigan State
  24. Marquette
  25. Clemson

And here is the BlogPoll (and you can click here for each blog’s entry as well as links to the other blogs).

  1. Memphis
  2. Tennessee
  3. Kansas
  4. Duke
  5. North Carolina
  6. UCLA
  7. Texas
  8. Xavier
  9. Stanford
  10. Butler
  11. Connecticut
  12. Wisconsin
  13. Georgetown
  14. Purdue
  15. Drake
  16. Louisville
  17. Washington State
  18. Indiana
  19. Notre Dame
  20. Michigan State
  21. St. Mary’s
  22. Kansas State
  23. Vanderbilt
  24. Marquette
  25. Clemson

I’m not going to go in depth comparing our entry with the final poll results but I will list teams that we like more and teams we like less than the rest of the blogosphere. I am picking these out by arbitrarily deciding teams we either overranked or underranked compared to the BlogPoll by at least 5 spots.


We Like More

Louisville

Kansas State

St. Mary’s

We Like Less

Wisconsin

Drake


Thoughts?

A Review of Thursday's Action

Health, schedule, and tiredness do not always allow me to get up the review of the evening's events that evening. Better now than never!

Duquesne 48 – Xavier 75

The thing you need to remember about this game is that Duquesne isn’t even that bad. Xavier is absolutely rolling.

Massachusetts 98 – Rhode Island 91

This was an interesting result. UMass really needed this win and now none of their final four games are all that tough (with the possible exception of a big one at Richmond; the good A-10 teams need Richmond to drop in the standings). Rhode Island is now in trouble having lost 4 of 5 but outside of a home game against St. Joseph’s, their remaining schedule isn’t too daunting. I think both of these teams still have a pulse.

Pittsburgh 70 – Notre Dame 82

A nice comeback leading to a comfortable double digit win has kept Notre Dame in the race for the Big East title. The Irish really are pretty good. Although Pitt is still in good shape for an at large bid that can go by the wayside with a couple more losses and they still have some losable games (Louisville, @Syracuse, and @ West Virginia among them).

Dayton 78 – La Salle 81

I’m simply running out of excuses for Dayton. This was a game they needed and now I imagine they need to win 3 of their final 4 as well as make some noise in the A-10 tournament. It’s a shame because I do still think this is a good team (and maybe the favorites to win the NIT this year).

South Alabama 69 – Western Kentucky 64

Now with two wins over Western Kentucky, USA has established themselves as a legit bubble team once again. Western Kentucky’s chances are probably over as their current best win is maybe over Middle Tennessee State. On the bright side for USA their conference tournament is being held in Mobile but that also means they should probably get less sympathy if they fail to nail down that automatic bid. The margin is still thin for USA.

Arizona State 47 – Washington State 59

Although losing to Washington State is never embarrassing Arizona State now is back in the mid-70s in the RPI and they sit below .500 in conference with 3 of their final 5 on the road (so things are not getting a whole lot easier for the Sun Devils). Despite some really high quality wins it’s an uphill battle for a bid and I don’t see them succeeding.

Oregon State 49 – UCLA 84

If the result were anything else it would be surprising. The Beavers are awful (but apparently not as bad as their record shows!).

Arizona 66 – Washington 75

This was also not a surprising result but it does mean Arizona’s bid is in jeopardy. The overall record isn’t very pretty, the conference record is under .500, and the computer numbers seem to be dropping (although still good). They’ve lost 4 of 5 and their next three games are @Washington State, USC, and UCLA. Good luck with that.

Oregon 75 – USC 81

USC is now in very good shape and they need to avoid disaster to get the bid. Their next game, at home against Oregon State, should provide their conference record with a bit of a cushion. On the other hand, Oregon is in trouble. They finish @UCLA, @Oregon State, Arizona State, and Arizona. They probably need to take three of those games and although possible it seems unlikely. Those games between Oregon and the Arizona schools could end up being huge bubble game battles.

Wednesday, February 20, 2008

A Moderately Interesting Wednesday Night Review

This was not a particularly fun and interesting Wednesday night but let’s look at the relevant results anyway.

Uninterestingly, a Good Team Beats a Bad Team

Penn State 49 – Michigan State 86

Marquette 73 – St. John’s 64

Auburn 70 – Tennessee 89

Memphis 97 – Tulane 71

Butler 51 – Illinois Chicago 46

Wisconsin 71 – Illinois 57

None of these results are particularly interesting or worth noting.

A Good Team Loses to a Bad Team

Kansas State 64 – Nebraska 71

Beasley thought he’d go for 50 tonight but instead his frustration level led him to apparently repeatedly attempt to eat his own arm. Although Kansas State’s loss won’t affect their bid this hurts their chances at the Big 12 title which will obviously affect seeding.

A Bubble Team Avoided a Loss

VCU 66 – Northeastern 62

South Carolina 82 – Florida 85

LSU 61 – Arkansas 87

New Mexico 68 – Air Force 51

Duke 95 – Miami 96

Utah 59 – BYU 67

I hesitated to even include VCU after the loss in their last game but I’ll give them the benefit of the doubt. Florida continues to not impress me after nearly losing a large second half lead in almost dropping another game against one of the weaker SEC teams. Arkansas, on the other hand, took care of business against a weak SEC team. It was probably kind of me to include New Mexico on this list at this point. I decided to give Miami the benefit of the doubt now and say they were a bubble team that avoided a loss. In fact, not only did they avoid a loss but they got a win over one of the best teams in the country (despite trying really, really hard to lose late) when that’s really the only thing that could keep them alive. BYU maintained their two game MWC lead and thus kept their at large hopes (should they need them) in pretty good shape.

Bubble Loss

Houston 99 – UAB 101

North Carolina 84 – NC State 70

West Virginia 56 – Villanova 78

Virginia Tech 69 – Maryland 65

Houston does not have the quality wins to survive this UAB loss. In fact, this clearly would have been their most quality win. I debated putting the UNC-NC State game in the first category but I decided to have this function as NC State’s coffin. I am not yet ready to place Villanova back on the bubble but if they can take their next two home games against Connecticut and Marquette they will leave me no choice. For West Virginia losing is one thing but they did not even show up. This doesn’t bode well for the rest of their year. This was a brutal loss for Maryland at home. They’re still maybe OK for now but at 7-5 and 3 of their last 4 on the road they still have work to do. All of a sudden Maryland’s trip to Miami this weekend is absolutely huge.

Bubble Battle

Mississippi State 63 – Mississippi 74

Mississippi won a game! It’s still not enough but it makes it so I cannot bury them quite yet. On the other hand, this was not a good outcome for a Mississippi State team that is essentially hanging its hat on its conference record. As that gets less impressive (in a not so impressive SEC) they are going to lose what they have going for them.

Tuesday, February 19, 2008

Tuesday Night in Review

Let's get right to an interesting night of games and I look forward to reading your comments!

Kent State 76 – Buffalo 66

Kent State avoided a crippling loss against a horrible team. This game could only hurt them but they didn’t let it.

Clemson 55 – Florida State 64

Although a good win for Florida State, they likely still need to win out to have a legit shot at a bid and that’s not happening. Clemson is still in fine shape for their at large bid but they’re in danger of falling out of that third team in the ACC range and obviously that would affect seeding.

DePaul 60 – Connecticut 65

This makes for back-to-back shaky wins against poor Big East competition for the Huskies. Their schedule isn’t that bad to end the year but escaping against teams like USF and DePaul is not a great sign. That said, they’ve still taken ten straight.

Purdue 68 – Indiana 77

The result of this game makes for an interesting battle for first in the Big 10 between these two schools and Wisconsin. In three of their last four games Indiana has worked on that pesky lack of big wins issue on their resume. Purdue now gets to return home for a couple breathers (Minnesota and Northwestern). Winning out in the regular season could do wonders for Purdue’s seed.

NC Greensboro 66 – Davidson 75

Davidson did what they needed to in avoiding a tough loss at home.

Baylor 91 – Oklahoma 92

On Saturday Baylor guard Aaron Bruce called a timeout with his team down 77-76 with 28 seconds left; he forgot the part where his team had no timeouts. Texas ended up winning 82-77. Tonight in overtime Baylor lead 91-88 with 7.3 seconds when Oklahoma guard Tony Crocker hit a three while being fouled by Bruce. It’s been a rough couple of days for the Aussie. Anyway, Crocker finishes off the three-point play. Baylor wasn’t dead yet as Curtis Jerrells was fouled with one second left but the 75% free throw shooter missed them both and the Sooners held on. I am not sold that the Big 12 is getting 6 bids and that means one of these two teams is getting left out. At this point Oklahoma is clearly ahead of Baylor in the pecking order and the Bears have some work to do. I’m not sure 8-8 in the Big 12 gets it done for Baylor.

Bradley 72 – Drake 71

Drake held a 69-60 lead late at home against Bradley before the Braves went on a 12-2 run to knock off Drake. Although this was not a good loss for Drake it’s not as bad as it looks on the surface to people that don’t know the Valley. Bradley’s record is severely deflated due to the injury to star guard Daniel Ruffin. The Braves are now 14-7 with Ruffin compared to 2-5 without him. Bradley is a terrific dark horse pick to possibly win Arch Madness.

Georgia 55 – Kentucky 61

I feel sick even talking about Kentucky but they are leaving me very little choice. At 8-3 in the conference, regardless of how bad they were out of conference, they need to be discussed. Their final 5 games are all difficult but as I mentioned, they are 8-3 right now in the SEC. If they can take 2 of their final 5 I have to think they’ll be considered and all I can do is root against it.

Chad vs. Joe Lunardi

With the update of my bubble rankings and Joe Lunardi's Bracketology update, it only makes sense to dedicate some time to comparing the two takes on the bubble. First, let's translate my bubble rankings in to the corresponding tournament seeds.

7: Texas A&M
8: Arizona,USC, Oklahoma, W. Virginia,
9: Baylor, Mississippi St., Arkansas, Syracuse,
10: St. Joe's, Oregon, Arizona St., Maryland
11: Wake Forest, Dayton, UMass, Rhode Island,
12: BYU, UNLV

Now let's compare that to Lunardi's seeding

7: A&M, Arizona, BYU
8: Pitt, USC, Baylor, Rhode Island
9: Gonzaga, Oklahoma, Mississippi, Maryland
10: Arizona St., UNLV, Ohio St., Arkansas
11: W. Virginia, Dayton, St. Joe's, S. Alabama
12: Syracuse, Oregon

Keep in mind that my seeding does not take into account any of the bracketing rules and that there is very little separating a lot of these teams. So I will not nitpick over a small difference in seeding between the two, but there are a few rather large discrepancies between the two brackets. First, Lunardi has two teams included in his bracket that are not in mine; Ohio St. and South Alabama. At this point, I don't even have S. Alabama as the top team in the Sun Belt, that honor goes to W. Kentucky. Yes, S. Alabama beat WKU in their first head-to-head matchup, but WKU has avoided losing to rest of the conference while S. Alabama has lost to North Texas and Middle Tennessee St. If there is a team that will get an at-large bid out of the Sun Belt, it will most likely come if WKU beats S. Alabama in the rematch and finishes the conference schedule with only one loss. And Ohio St??????? Not only does Lunardi have the Buckeyes in his bracket, but he has them as a #10 seed. Let's recap Ohio State's resume: two decent non-conference wins over Syracuse and Florida (both at home), ZERO wins against the top four teams in the Big Ten (Purdue, Michigan St, Indiana, Wisconsin) and two HORRIBLE losses at Michigan and Iowa. In case I need to use more capitalization to make my point clear, OHIO STATE IS NOT A TOURNAMENT TEAM at this point. In fact, now that I write this I have come to the conclusion that I have the Buckeyes ranked too highly in my rankings. Now they do have upcoming games with all four of the top Big Ten teams, so they do have opportunities for picking up some big wins, but they also have the opportunity to finish at .500 in a weak conference.

The two teams that I have in the tourney that Lunardi excludes are Wake Forest and UMass. Lunardi has UMass in his "Last Four Out" so there isn't much of a difference there. As for Wake Forest, I may have given them a little too much credit for their win over Duke, but even if I lower them slightly in my rankings, they are still in my bracket. To justify my ranking of Wake Forest, let's compare their resume to that of Maryland. WF is 6-5 in the ACC, while Maryland is 7-4. Both have one win over one of the top two teams in the ACC (WF over Duke, Maryland over UNC). Maryland is 1-3 vs. the RPI top 50, while WF is 3-3; Maryland is 6-5 vs. RPI 50-100, while WF is 3-4. Both have one loss to an RPI 100+ team (Maryland to American, WF to Georgia). So what all of this says to me is that there is very little separating these two teams, yet Lunardi has Maryland as a 9 seed and WF out, while I have both as 10 seeds.

A few more notable discrepancies...
What does Lunardi see in BYU? Yes, they've avoided the bad loss outside of a loss to Boise St., but is that enough to earn a #7 seed? Maybe I should have a little separation in my rankings between BYU and UNLV but I would have a hard time having BYU seeded any higher than a #10 seed. And I feel good about having UNLV as a #12 seed. They did not get a signature win during non-conference play while losing at UCSB and have now lost to Utah and Air Force in conference. If it weren't for their win over BYU, they wouldn't even be on the bubble.

Lunardi has Rhode Island a #8 seed, while I have URI as a #11 seed. I'm not sure how Lunardi can justify having URI seeded above St. Joe's unless he knew that St. Joe's would lose to La Salle last night. URI has some nice non-conference wins (Syracuse and UAB) but those are balanced out by losses to St. Louis and Temple. But more than that, I don't know how Lunardi can say that there is so much separation between the A-10 teams that URI deserves a #8 seed while St. Joe and Dayton are #11 seeds.

I have Syracuse as a #9 seed and Lunardi has the Orangemen at a #12 seed On further inspection it looks like Lunardi moved Syracuse from a #11 to a #12 for bracketing purposes and I have Syracuse as my fourth #9 seed, so there really isn't a big difference here.

Monday, February 18, 2008

Special President's Day Monday Wrap-Up

Georgetown 68 – Providence 58

With 3 of their final 4 games at home, including a regular season finale against fellow 11-3 Big East school Louisville, Georgetown is probably in the best position to win the conference even if I think they’re pretty grossly overrated. Still, winning at Providence isn’t completely easy so this was a nicely avoided pitfall.

Syracuse 50 – Louisville 61

The double-digit win was not indicative of how close this game was but that doesn’t do Syracuse much good now. The Orange finish @Notre Dame, Pittsburgh, @Seton Hall, and Marquette. That’s a tough finish and you have to figure they need at least two of the games to get to 9-9 and have a shot at a bid. I’m not 100% sure that 9-9 would be good enough.

Xavier 81 – Rhode Island 77

Xavier is about too good for the A-10s good. If they would give up a loss here or there they could give other teams quality wins that may desperately need them. It’s funny that their only loss in conference has been to Temple and they got destroyed in that game. They are looking at a fantastic seed come March. Rhode Island has now lost 3 of 4. They still have strong computer numbers and they have two huge opportunities for wins with home games against Massachusetts and St. Joseph’s this week.

La Salle 90 – St. Joseph’s 89

St. Joseph’s could have cemented themselves as the number two team in the A-10 if they could only beat freaking La Salle. Obviously freaking La Salle beat them. I really have no explanation as to how this happened. Luckily (or unluckily if you consider they can’t beat La Salle at home) they still have chances against some of the other big guns in the conference as they still travel to Rhode Island and Dayton and host Xavier in their final five games. If St. Joseph’s wants to be a tournament team they still have a chance to show it but tonight was certainly a horrible step in the completely wrong direction.

Texas A&M 50 – Texas 77

OK, I understand losing to Texas as a follow-up to that bad home loss against Oklahoma State, but you have to be more competitive than this. This is now three thorough beat-downs in the conference slate for the Aggies. Although they get a bye in their next game at home against Nebraska then they have to face a Texas Tech team that beat them by 15, travel to Oklahoma and Baylor and then come back home to face Kansas. Texas A&M’s at large bid is far from secure. This is just yet another quality win for a Longhorn team that I am begrudgingly beginning to accept might be pretty good. If Texas wins out in the regular season they should get consideration for a one seed.

St. Mary’s 100 – Pepperdine 64

What a three point barrage for the Gaels as they go 17-29 from three. Dubois Williams (0-2) must feel like an idiot. Hell, even Carlin Hughes (4-8) was bringing the team down. St. Mary’s stays in great shape and now has a week off as they prepare to get their revenge on San Diego.

Gonzaga 59 – San Diego 55

San Diego has already beaten St. Mary’s at the Jenny Craig Pavilion and this was a close loss to Gonzaga. It was a big win for Gonzaga to keep their at large hopes alive and well. The biggest thing to note here is that San Diego is certainly capable of beating St. Mary’s and Gonzaga at home and the WCC conference tournament will be played at USD. With the way the rest of the country is unfolding, if the Toreros take the automatic bid a three-bid year for the WCC is not completely out of the question.

Sunday, February 17, 2008

NCAA Bubble Rankings - Feb. 18

Since last week a lot has happened in college basketball and that is reflected in this week's bubble rankings. In my opinion one team, Vanderbilt, has moved off the bubble and are now in very good shape to earn a bid. Three teams have been added to the bubble: Texas A&M (lost at home to Oklahoma St.), Baylor (losses to Texas and at Oklahoma St.) and Kent St (wins over C. Michigan and Ohio). In addition a number of teams have been dropped off the bubble for the time being and are listed following the rankings. Some of these teams could go an a run and get back to the bubble, but at this point it seems highly unlikely.

1. Texas A&M - the loss at home to Oklahoma St. is puzzling for a team that has been very good at home all season long
2. Arizona - losses to Arizona St. and Stanford don't hurt the Wildcats but prevent Arizona from moving off the bubble
3. USC - another win over UCLA would have moved the Trojans off the bubble. USC is still in good shape, but need to stay above .500 to avoid sweating it out on Selection Sunday.
4. Oklahoma - wins over Iowa St. and Texas Tech were more about avoiding questionable losses than improving their tournament resume
5. Baylor - The Bears have now lost 5 of their last 6. Finishing at .500 in the Big 12 is a real possibility for Baylor and that may not be enough to earn an at-large bid.
6. West Virginia - The Mountaineers avoided bad losses with wins over Rutgers and Seton Hall.
7. Mississippi State - The Bulldogs make the biggest jump in the rankings thanks to their win over Arkansas and they are now 8-2 in the SEC
8. Arkansas - The Razorbacks lost two games to likely tournament teams (Tennessee and Mississippi St.)
9. Syracuse - To be honest, I wasn't sure where to rank Syracuse after their week. Their loss to USF is close to unforgivable, but the win over Georgetown prevents me from moving them much.
10. St. Joe's - St. Joe avoided a bad loss by blowing out St. Bonaventure
11. Oregon - The Ducks split with the Washington schools, winning over UW before losing the WSU. They likley will need to pick up a win over USC or UCLA this week to remain ranked this highly.
12. Arizona State - The win over Stanford will likely carry more weight with the committee than the loss to Cal, so the Sundevils move up slightly.
13. Maryland - The Terps missed out on a chance to lock up a bid by winning over Duke, but did follow the loss up with a win over Florida St.
14. Wake Forest - WF makes a big jump on to the "right side" of the bubble with wins over Florida St. and Duke.
15. Dayton - Dayton, Rhode Island, and UMass all suffered questionable losses this week and there is now very little separating these three A-10 teams
16. Rhode Island
17. Massachusetts
18. UNLV - BYU defeated UNLV to split the season series. Very little separates these two teams.
19. Brigham Young
20. Miami (FL) - The Hurricanes picked up a nice road win at Georgia Tech and are now sitting squarely on the bubble.
21. Ohio State - The Buckeyes suffered a bad loss at Michigan. Add in their loss at Iowa and the fact that they have yet to pick up a victory against the top 4 teams in the Big 10 and OSU is currently on the wrong side of the bubble.
22. Florida - the loss to LSU drops the Gators
23. Villanova - Villanova may have needed the win over Georgetown in order to move into contention for a bid.
24. Houston - It will be very interesting to see how the committee handles Houston if they finish with only two losses in C-USA (both to Memphis)
26. NC State
- losses to BC and Clemson put the Wolfpack in danger of falling off the bubble. They will likely need to win one of their upcoming games with Duke or UNC to stay in contention for an at-large bid
27. Kentucky - a 7-3 record in the SEC with wins over Vandy and Tennessee is keeping UK on the bubble but they have very little room for error
28. Davidson - Davidson keeps winning and they likely need to keep winning if they want an at-large bid. I may have them ranked a little low but outside of staying close in losses to UNC, Duke, and UCLA there's not much to their resume. The early season losses to Charlotte and NC State may be the difference if Davidson does not receive an at-large bid.
29. Western Kentucky - Another team that needs to keep winning to have a shot at a bid. A win this week over S. Alabama could go a long ways towards getting that bid.
30. S. Alabama - Their loss to MTSU puts them in danger of falling off the bubble. The loser of the WKU/S. Alabama game will likely not be included in next weeks rankings.
30. Kent St. - They have separated themselves from the pack in the Mid-American with their win over Ohio. But being better than everyone else in the Mid-American likely isn't enough to deserve an at-large bid.

Teams that have dropped of the bubble
Florida St.
Mississippi
Illinois St.
George Mason
Creighton
Virginia Tech
Seton Hall
Oral Roberts


Sunday College Basketball Review

Here we go! As always, we appreciate comments!

Notre Dame 71 – Rutgers 68

If the Irish can beat Pitt and Syracuse in South Bend in their next two games they’ll sit 11-3 in conference and possibly in position to win the Big East. Notre Dame is looking at a pretty good seed.

Ohio State 70 – Michigan 80

Ohio State is in trouble. They’re a mediocre 8-5 in a weak Big 10 and their last five games are Wisconsin, @Indiana, @Minnesota, Purdue, and Michigan State. Wow, they could lose all of those! I imagine they need to take at least three of those games and that’s not going to be easy. I think Ohio State is still in right now but today might have been a must win. The Buckeyes still have a chance to pick up some big wins and cement their bid but they have a great chance at losing enough games to be looking at a good NIT seed.

Virginia 79 – Boston College 74

This was a killer loss for Boston College. Losing to Virginia is one thing but losing at home is enough to kill the season for a team that likely needed a lot of help anyway. The list of ACC teams that could potentially earn a bid is shrinking.

Miami 64 – Georgia Tech 63

Going 2-0 on this road trip has kept Miami alive but we’ll see how they respond in their next three games (Duke, Maryland, @Clemson). They still are 4-6 in conference and it would do them well to get back to .500 in conference. Their final three games this year are not too daunting. Georgia Tech, on the other hand, has lost 4 of 5 and is beyond dead.

Seton Hall 68 – West Virginia 89

This was a game West Virginia couldn’t afford to lose and they won easily. They’d likely be in the field if the tournament started today but with 4 of their final 6 on the road things can change. If Seton Hall wasn’t already dead they are now.

Saint Louis 77 – Massachusetts 88

Going into Sunday losses in 5 of their 7 games has put Massachusetts on the wrong side of the bubble. They’re still on the wrong side but the win today allowed them to at least stay on the bubble. They’re game Thursday at Rhode Island will be huge for the Minutemen.

Charlotte 51 – Fordham 53

Charlotte needed to do a lot to get in position to earn a bid and the loss to Fordham is not putting them in that position. They are likely done.

Duke 73 – Wake Forest 86

With this win Wake has created separation between them and the bottom group in the ACC. Duke, North Carolina, Clemson, and likely Maryland all sit ahead of Wake Forest in the ACC at large bid pecking order but Wake Forest would clearly sit at number five and with the lack of teams around the country looking at large worthy they might be in if the tournament started today. Despite the loss Duke should be in good position for a number one seed for now.

UCLA 56 – USC 46

Sweeping the season series for USC would have been huge and might have punched their ticket. They’re still in good shape and with 4 of their final 6 games at the Galen Center, the future looks good as well. With the win the Bruins are now in decent shape to nab a number one seed; it would be hard to justify a one seed for the Bruins if they do not take the Pac 10 regular season title but they’re in the driver’s seat now.